The hook went in just past the barb, right at the base of my left thumb. It was the second Saturday in April, the water still cool enough that the bass were sluggish and I was throwing a squarebill just to have something to do. I was pulling a treble out of that crankbait on the bank of a farm pond outside Dothan, and the bait kicked sideways when I leaned over it. That is all it takes. One second you are unhooking a bait, the next second you are hooked to it.
What I had in the truck box was a pair of needle-nose pliers with a jaw that had worn slick over about twenty years of use. Good pliers once. That is the reason the Piscifun Fishing Pliers are in my box now and that old needle-nose is in a drawer in the shed. I had already tried the usual things that afternoon. I pinched the hook shank with my fingers, which accomplished nothing except making my thumb throb. Then I worked the bend of the hook with the needle-nose, and it slid off three times running because the teeth were gone. That afternoon they would not bite on a hook shank worth a nickel. My brother-in-law Earl held the line steady while I worked, and it took us the better part of ten minutes and a pair of side cutters to get my thumb back. Earl did not say much. He did not have to.
That evening I ordered the Piscifun pliers. Not because I had read something good about them. Because I was mad, and I wanted a tool in that box that would bite when I told it to.
I have carried them now for two full seasons. They have been dropped on a boat ramp at Lake Eufaula, rained on twice, left in the floor of the jon boat, and used to cut braid, pinch barbs, and pull hooks out of more bream and crappie than I can count. They are still in the box. That is more than I can say for the needle-nose. The aluminum has picked up a few scratches where it rides against my bait knife, but aluminum scratches. It does not bend, and it has not seized up on me yet.
A pair of pliers that will not bite on a hook shank is not a tool. It is a thing taking up space in your box.
The tool I should have had in the box that afternoon
Spring-loaded jaws, aluminum handles, replaceable tungsten carbide cutters. Check today's price on Amazon before your next trip to the pond.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →Here is what changed for me, and it is not a complicated list. The jaws close flush and they stay closed on a hook shank. The spring keeps the handles open so I can work them with one hand while the other hand holds a fish or a rod. On a bank with a bream flopping around, one-handed operation is most of the job. The first real test came in June, a channel cat that had swallowed a circle hook down where I could not see it. The Piscifun pliers went in at the bend, turned, and backed the hook out clean in maybe fifteen seconds. The old needle-nose would have had me cutting line and retying.
Cutters matter more than people give them credit for. Braid does not cut with a dull edge. It slides. The tungsten carbide cutters on the Piscifun pliers go through 20-pound braid in one squeeze, and when they eventually wear out, they are replaceable. I have not had to swap mine yet, but I like knowing the option exists instead of throwing the whole tool away.
The handles are aluminum with an ergonomic grip and the whole thing weighs 3.6 ounces. That sounds like a spec sheet talking, but it means something when the pliers live on your belt instead of in the box. I carry mine in the nylon sheath on my hip when I am wading the creek near the house, and I forget it is there until I need it. The truck-box needle-nose pulled my belt sideways all day.
They are rated for saltwater by the maker. I fish sweet water, so I cannot tell you much about that. What I can tell you is that mine have been wet, sandy, and forgotten on a boat seat overnight, and the pivot still moves free with no rust I have found.
What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table
If you are standing in your shed right now looking at a pair of pliers that came out of a multi-tool or a bargain bin, do yourself a favor and put a real pair in your box. Not because a hook in the thumb is the end of the world. Because it is the sort of thing that ends a fishing trip early, and you will be mad about it for a week.
Keep the sheath on your belt and the pliers in the sheath, not in the bottom of the boat where you have to dig. Pinch your barbs down if you are fishing catch and release, and use the cutters when a hook is set too deep to back out. I keep a spare spool of 20-pound braid in the box and I trim every tag with those same cutters, standing right there on the bank. That is the whole system. It costs less than a good crankbait and it lasts longer than most of them.
One honest complaint: the sheath is nylon, and nylon does not love a wet boat floor. Mine has stiffened up a little over two seasons. I still use it. I just do not expect it to look new, and it does not.
Earl bought a pair after he watched me cut a hook out of a catfish jaw with one squeeze. He had been carrying the same rusty needle-nose since I have known him, and he is not a man who buys things. He does not compliment tools. He just borrows them. When he bought his own, that was the review.
If you want the full breakdown of how these have held up over two seasons, I wrote that up separate. If you are still deciding between these and a plain needle-nose, I wrote that one too. Both are worth ten minutes of your evening before you spend money.
Put a pair in the box before the next trip
Two seasons, one thumb, and a retired needle-nose. See today's price on Amazon and keep one on your belt.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →