Two combos have been leaning against the wall of my shed since March, and I have stopped pretending one of them wins outright. On the left is the Ugly Stik Complete Spincast kit, seven feet of rod and reel that came out of the same box. On the right is the open-face spinning combo I have carried for years, a Pflueger President 30 sitting on a shorter medium rod. Here is the short answer before I get long-winded. If you fish farm ponds from the bank, drown worms for bream, soak cut bait for catfish, or hand a rod to a nephew who fishes twice a summer, the Ugly Stik kit is the one that leaves the shed with you. If you are on open water at Eufaula throwing a light jig into a west wind, the spinning combo is the one you keep for yourself.
Neither of those is a knock on the other. It is a question of what each rig was built to solve. The spincast kit removes the ways a beginner fails. No bail to flip, no spool to thumb, no bird's nest to pick out in the gray light while the fish quit biting. The spinning combo does the opposite. It hands more control to somebody who already knows what he is doing, over distance, lure weight and where the line lands. That trade is the whole comparison. Everything below is just detail on it.
| Ugly Stik Spincast Kit | Pflueger President Spinning Combo | |
|---|---|---|
| First cast for a beginner | Push-button cast, no bail to flip, no backlash to pick out | Needs a five-minute lesson on the bail and the drag before it stops scaring people |
| Distance into wind | Seven feet of medium-heavy rod will push a bait out there, but the closed face runs out of steam | An open spool releases cleaner and carries a lure farther into a west wind |
| Lures under an eighth of an ounce | Struggles. Small jigs and finesse plastics do not load the rod | Handles light jigs and small plastics with real control |
| Line choice | Spooled with monofilament and happiest staying that way | Will take mono, fluorocarbon or braid depending on what you spool on it |
| Backlash and bird's nests | None. The line stays inside the closed face | A careless thumb costs you ten minutes on the bank |
| Rod warranty | Seven years from the manufacturer | Standard cover, and a broken tip usually means buying a rod |
| Packing in a truck | Two-piece telescopic, breaks down short behind a seat | Two-piece as well, and it packs fine |
| Turning a bass out of cover | Medium-heavy power rated to 14-pound line gives you backbone when a fish gets in the stumps | Depends entirely on the rod you pair the reel with |
| Handedness | Ambidextrous, the handle swaps to either side | Most spinning reels are reversible too |
| Best for | Farm ponds, bank fishing, guests and grandkids | Open reservoir water, light lures, the angler who fishes twice a week |
What the Ugly Stik Kit Actually Is
The kit is a seven-foot, two-piece rod with a telescopic tip, medium-heavy power, and a closed-face reel already spooled with monofilament. The guides are six stainless steel, the kind with no ceramic insert to pop out on a cold morning. The grips are EVA foam, which matters more than it sounds like it does when your hands are wet and you are trying to set a hook. The reel body is aluminum. The whole rig weighs 0.95 kg. The handle is ambidextrous, so a left-handed guest is not standing on the bank holding a rod backwards and apologizing.
Line capacity is 280 yards of 12-pound mono, and the rod is rated for 14-pound line, which is more than a pond bream will ever need and about right for a bass in a stump bed. There is one ball bearing in the reel, and you can feel that when you crank fast. It is rated for bass and trout. The part that surprised me is the warranty. Seven years from the manufacturer on the rod. I have owned trucks with less coverage than that.
None of this is fancy, and the people at Ugly Stik clearly know it. This thing was built to be handed to somebody who has never fished, and to survive being set down on gravel, stepped over in a jon boat, and left in the truck bed overnight because you were tired and it was starting to rain. I have done all three to mine and the rod is still straight.
Seven years of manufacturer warranty on a rod that rides in a truck bed and gets rained on. That tells you who Ugly Stik expects to be using it.
The Spinning Combo, Briefly
The other rig is the standard open-face setup most anglers graduate into. An exposed spool, a bail you flip by hand, a drag knob you set before the first cast. Mine is a Pflueger President 30 on a shorter medium rod, and it has been to the Gulf and back twice and never given me a real problem. It weighs about the same as the kit and carries fewer yards of line than the Ugly Stik does.
What it has that the kit does not is control. You decide when the line leaves the spool and how fast. That sounds like a small thing until you are casting into a crosswind at a point that has fish on it, and then it is the only thing. The cost is that you have to learn it. A spinning reel punishes a lazy thumb, and it does it in front of whoever came along with you.
How I Tested Both
I fished the kit for four months, mostly the way I actually fish, which is often and not especially well. Farm ponds outside Dothan for bream and largemouth. The creek behind the house when it comes up muddy. Two mornings on Eufaula with my brother-in-law Earl, who brought his own tackle and his own opinions and shared both. Tater sat on the bank through most of it and stole a bait bucket lid once. The rod got dropped on a concrete ramp, rained on twice, and rode home in the bed of the Silverado more times than I will admit.
The first morning out was the last week of March, water still cold and stained, and I caught exactly one bass on a slow-rolled spinnerbait. Nothing about that morning told me a thing about the rod. The morning that did was in May, on the pond off the county road, when I laid both rigs in the boat and cast them back to back at a windblown corner for two hours. Same bait, same corner, same wind pushing down the length of the water. That is the morning I keep coming back to when I try to be fair about this.
I ran the spinning combo side by side on the same water, with the same baits where I could manage it. That is the only honest way to compare two rods. Cast both, on the same morning, into the same wind, at the same fish. What follows is what held up and what did not, and I have not rounded anything in my own favor.
Where Ugly Stik Wins
The first win has nothing to do with fishing skill. You can put this rod in the hands of somebody who has never cast in their life and they will be fishing in about five minutes. The push button does the work. No bail to flip, no spool to feather with a thumb, no backlash to pick out while the morning burns off. I handed it to Earl's grandson at a pond in June and the boy was hauling bream out before I finished rigging my own line. On the spinning combo, that same kid would have spent twenty minutes learning what his thumb is for and another ten being teased about it.
The second win is durability, and it is the warranty talking, not a slogan. Seven years on the rod. Six stainless guides with no inserts to lose. EVA grips that stay grippy when they are wet, which is most of July in southeast Alabama. I dropped this rod on the ramp at the creek and stepped on it in the bottom of the jon boat, and it came out of both fine. A spinning rod is not fragile by nature, but every one I have owned died the same way, either a tip snapped in a truck door or a guide insert cracked and started chewing line.
The third is packing. Two-piece with a telescopic tip means it breaks down short enough to go behind the truck seat instead of riding in the bed where sun and gravel get at it. I have kept mine behind the seat of the Silverado with a rag wrapped around the reel since June, and it has been ready every time I wanted it. Earl laughed at that arrangement until the afternoon his own rod tangled in the trolling motor handle while mine was already rigged and sitting in the water. One caution on the telescopic tip. It has to be fed back in slow and straight or it will bind, and the first time I rushed it I was sure I had ruined the rod. I had not.
The combo that shrugs off a concrete ramp and a rainy truck bed
Seven feet, two pieces, a seven-year rod warranty, and a closed face that will not bird's nest on a beginner. Check today's price and current availability on Amazon.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →Where the Spinning Combo Wins
Distance, and it is not close. An open spool releases line cleaner than a closed face ever will, and on a big reservoir where the fish are forty yards off the grass, that gap decides whether you are fishing or just practicing. On Eufaula in April I could reach a wind-blown point with the spinning combo that the Ugly Stik kit left about ten yards short on every cast. Ten yards is not much. It was also where the fish were.
There was a morning that month when the bass were holding off that point and would not come any closer to the boat. I caught two on the spinning combo and none on the kit, and I want to be honest that the difference was not my skill. It was reach. The kit put the bait in the right neighborhood. The open spool put it on the porch and knocked. If most of your fishing is done within thirty yards of the bank, none of this matters and you can ignore the whole section.
Light lures are the second loss. Below about an eighth of an ounce the closed face quits loading the rod properly, and you feel it as a mushy, short cast that lands in a pile at your feet. Small jigs, finesse plastics, a little inline spinner for creek bass, the spinning combo handles all of it. The kit handles maybe half. If your fishing is small baits and finicky fish, that one row should decide the whole thing for you and you can stop reading here.
The third is line. The kit comes spooled with monofilament and it is a monofilament reel by design. A spinning spool will take mono, fluorocarbon or braid depending on what you put on it, and changing over is a five-minute job at the kitchen table with a pair of scissors. That flexibility is worth something to anybody who fishes more than one way in a season, and it is worth nothing to a man who spools up once a year whether he needs to or not.
What I Liked
- Casts in five minutes for somebody who has never held a rod
- No backlash to pick out, ever
- Seven-year manufacturer warranty on the rod
- Two-piece telescopic breaks down short behind a truck seat
- EVA foam grips stay useful with wet hands
- Ambidextrous handle works in either hand
Where It Falls Short
- One ball bearing, and you feel it on a fast crank
- Lures under about an eighth of an ounce cast poorly
- Medium-heavy power is more rod than a bream pond needs
- Spooled with monofilament and happiest staying that way
- Will not out-cast an open spool into wind
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the Ugly Stik kit if you fish ponds and creeks from the bank. If you keep a rod behind the truck seat for whenever the mood hits. If you take kids, guests, or a brother-in-law who fishes twice a year and needs to be fishing instead of untangling. If you want one combo that will still be working when a seven-year warranty runs out. It is also the right call for a jon boat angler who wants a spare rig that does not need babysitting while he fishes something else.
If you are buying for a young angler, buy the kit and do not overthink it. A kid catching bream on a push button at eight years old will want an open spool by twelve, and by then he can buy his own with lawn-mowing money. What you do not want is to hand a child a spinning rig in March and have him quit the sport by April because of a bird's nest he could not pick out. I have watched that happen to a neighbor's boy, and the rod went in the garage and never came back out.
Buy the spinning combo if you fish open water and need the distance, if your box is full of light jigs and small plastics, if you want to run braid, or if you already know what your thumb is for and you want the control that comes with an open spool. There is a middle case too, and it is probably the most common one. Two rods, one of each. The kit lives in the truck for ponds and grandchildren. The spinning combo comes out when the water opens up and the wind starts.
One box, one rig, and a rod warranty longer than most folks keep a truck
If the pond or the creek is where you fish, this is the combo that gets handed to whoever came along. Check today's price and availability on Amazon.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →